Thursday, October 24, 2013

Group Interactions

I probably had the most ideal group situation in the course, which has never happened before, despite the dozens of group projects I have participated in. It was a course I was taking as an elective for my minor. The topics themselves were interesting, but I knew the content of the course would not help if I were the only one doing all of the work. I know many others in the same boat. Typically, there is a leader of the group that assigns themselves to keep the project from ultimately failing. Collaboratively, everyone else decides what part of the project he or she wants to do. Sometimes, individuals get lucky with the “easy” part while others get suck with doing the part they were hoping they wouldn’t have to do. But for my first example in this parallel comparison, the difficulties of group work were almost non-existent.

I don’t know if it was just because I liked the people I was grouped with, or if we understood each other and were floating in the same boat, or even if our skills just perfectly balanced. Maybe it was a hint of each. I have never participated in a more efficient and supportive group of individuals, and honestly I probably never will again. The group dynamics were incredible in my situation. Even as we sat together for the first time to discuss our goal and the steps we would to achieve it, there was no tension or stress. It was very comfortable working with them and the smoothness we experienced throughout the entire process demonstrated that they felt the same as well. We were all a part of a well-oiled machine and the way we interacted with each other ultimately drove us to achieve the highest grade in the class. Of course, like any other group, there was conflict between information, communication, and the project content, but issues were resolved soundly without negatively affecting performance or hindering the ability to complete the tasks at hand.

On a completely different world and in a completely different situation, I had a more traumatic experience with a group project. For this second example, I was enrolled in a required class for my major. We needed to complete a project that required a lot of collaboration since quantitative content was necessary to complete it. The subject matter we were dealing with was more difficult than a typical project, and required more math and analysis, which I believe are attributes that need to be fully understood in order to incorporate them into a project. For this group, there were individuals who knew the matter, and others who did not, making it more difficult for the entire group to be on the same page. While I do not blame the couple that did not know the material as well, since it was certainly difficult, it made our group situation more off balance. Additionally, this caused frustration, as we were more focused on trying to get concepts down rather than accomplishing the project.

A lot of times, from my experience, when individuals do not have the commitment to learn the content and count on free-riding from others, it puts a stress on the group that can hinder it from accomplishing the goals at hand. While people don’t need to be the most talented or the smartest, the way they work and handle their own assignments affects their group performance. In my first example, each individual was responsible for his or her own actions. If someone did not understand anything, they would first try and look through their notes or do their own research before asking the group. In my second example, those who did not understand relied heavily on their group members. While it’s not terrible to ask for help, when participating in group projects it can be assumed that you have the ability to work individually and you know what you are doing. When you don’t, and others have to baby you through the process, the overall quality and effectiveness of working in a group decreases.

Monday, October 21, 2013

Team Production vs Individual Production




At one of my previous job positions, the contribution of a group of individuals produced more effective and efficient output than the contribution of the individuals themselves. There was 10-12 of us working identical, front-line positions in the office earning the same hourly wage. With the type of substantial projects our managers assigned in order to offer services to a diverse population, we needed each other’s help. Typically, our team progressed towards a common goal with each project, all the while completing our own individual, specialized tasks. Cooperation and communication were the two most important elements in completing the larger, collective duties. Weekly meetings, e-mail updates, and an understanding on how to collaborate aided in fulfilling deadlines and objectives.

The main endeavors that required the most collective work revolved around large events and programs where everyone needed to contribute in order for the organization to pull it off. Particular tasks did not need any sort of specialized skills to complete; therefore, since everyone had the ability to accomplish the bulk of the preparations it was easy to hand off responsibilities. This sometimes created problems of tracking who did what. Organization of which employee contributed to what task was probably the most difficult endeavor to pinpoint for our managers, as monitoring us was not always possible. This also allowed certain individuals to be credited for some projects they only worked an hour on. On the other hand, others working on the same project contributed their entire shifts to try and complete it. Unless the managers specifically assigned an individual to finish the assignment, whoever is in the office at the time and completes it is usually credited, despite the number of people working on it before.

This also gets complicated when something goes wrong or there are mistakes found in the work. Sometimes we cannot backtrack unless responsibility is taken and another individual who was doing a majority of the project mistake-free has to go back and fix what was messed up. Not being able to distinguish individual contributions can make motivation for completing large tasks difficult. But being able to filter certain decisions down to all the employees, allowing us to participate in the decision-making process. This enables us to feel that our opinions actually matter.

In regards to the opinion article, “How to Get the Rick to Share the Marbles,” there were a few concepts that I believed coincided with my experience. While my co-workers and I are not monetarily compensated based on our performance, as we are contracted to an hourly-wage, our version of “share-the-spoils” is employee recognition. If everyone does their “fair share” and pulls on the rope just as hard as everyone else, everyone deserves credit and recognition.

Monday, September 30, 2013

Managing Income Risk


Until I began my undergraduate career, I never realized how important the significant decisions I have made in the past would impact my future. I came into the University of Illinois with very strong intentions on going to medical school. I had experience in the hospital while I was in high school. I was a part of a junior’s medical program. I worked in and volunteered my time to the industry. Originally, I believed my familiarity with medicine, in combination with the pre-requisite coursework, would cushion my prospective medical career. However, I quickly realized that I had made the wrong decisions in picking a major I was unable to maintain a high GPA for, thus forcing me to accept a rather disappointing fallout.

I felt like my low GPA was a high debt I accumulated after just one year into college (my grades were bankrupt, if you will). And low GPAs come with a lot of risks that can create a snowball effect. There was the risk of Academic Probation, ineligibility for financial aid, and of course disqualification from jobs and professional programs from being unable to graduate. My future in medicine was slowly crumbling before me because I was enrolled in a degree program that did not match my interests and strengths. At this point, my future income risk was high and I needed to adjust certain aspects of my education to pay off my “academic debt.”

My GPA was only a factor that contributed to how gradually I reduced my income risk. I additionally took on a part-time job on campus, which helped repair some of the damage. I was able to invest my earnings and gain marketable skills for potential employment opportunities. While I had the my overarching goal of getting my GPA back up to more profitable numbers, I needed to accomplish the baby steps in order to get there. One of the major stepping-stones that helped boost my GPA the most was switching majors and adding a minor I was passionate about. Through trial and error, I finally was able to capitalize on the courses I excelled in, ultimately guiding my decision to pursue an Economics Major. Economics and business is obviously a completely different career path than science and medicine, but I needed to base my decisions on what would positively impact me both in the now and future. Eventually, summers in hospitals and medical centers turned into summers in banks and corporate offices.

On the actual financial side of my university career, I have accumulated debt (like the average college student), but not a significant quantity. My parents are in charge of a substantial amount of my educational finances, and I have lent a helping hand seeing my future is the one being affected the most. With payments over the minimum, my refunds and part-time paychecks going into my housing and basic living expenses, and my mother being eligible for having a majority of her loan forgiven, I firmly believe I am in a good position for the future.

Friday, September 20, 2013

Un-opportunistically

The practice of opportunism largely portrays individuals who take advantage of an opportunity to achieve an end, many times with no regard for the great risk of negative consequences. Typically, those acting on opportunism lack honor in principle. That is, their behavior in the situation attempts to selfishly gain some sort of power or benefit. A quote that I have always thought about related to this policy is from former NBA player Michael Jordan:

“To be successful you have to be selfish, or else you never achieve. And once you get to your highest level, then you have to be unselfish.”

His claim basically says to first be selfish until you get on top, and then once you are on top be humble and grounded.

Of course, not everyone has the same grain of wisdom as the NBA superstar. I feel that nowadays, it’s changed to:
“To be successful you have to be selfish, or else you never achieve. And once you get to your highest level, then you have to be even more selfish so you can stay there.”
But there have been certain situations where I have witnessed ethical behavior as a Good Samaritan shines through. One in particular was a story that a former mentor told me. This woman was a doctor at a nationally ranked medical center hospital located in downtown Chicago. She was speaking of her career track from undergraduate school, to medical school, to residency, and then finally opening her own practice. In her story, she described the difficulties of medical school. She went on about one of the biggest incidents that could have destroyed her entire medical career.

In one of her courses, they had to conduct an experiment and produce a liquid solution perfectly to pass. She was an intelligent African-American woman and one of the top students in her class. Many saw her as competition.

She completed her project in the classroom, walked a way for a second, and then returned. When she came back, one of her classmates pulled her aside. She was confused, thinking she did the experiment wrong. But he, instead, whispered to her saying one of the other male students put something in her solution, so she would fail the project. She was in complete shock.

Immediately, she approached her professor, not wanting to confront her perpetrator. In the end, he was kicked out of his medical program, she got another opportunity to re-do the experiment, and she passed.

The opportunism here does not focus on the cheating culprit who took advantage of the opportunity of her stepping away from her experiment. The chance for opportunistic behavior is when her classmate chose to tell her that another student tampered with the results of her experiment. The competition involved in medical school motivates individuals to be extremely selfish. But her classmate chose the ethical path. He could have changed the circumstances for his own gains by letting the incident slip, but he didn’t, and told her the truth instead.

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

Organization Structure and Transaction Costs

This past summer 2013, I interned at the headquarters for Marriott International, Inc. in Bethesda, MD. Marriott is a large organization, mainly known for their thousands of lodging properties both in the United States and internationally as well. This company operates, franchises, and manages 19 brands, some of which include The Ritz-Carlton, JW Marriott, and Renaissance Hotels.

As a Fortune 200 company, the organizational structure was bureaucratic. Everyone had a specific job function, meaning their roles and responsibilities were defined and followed. There was also a clear hierarchal structure. I was part of a large overall team, the department of Public Relations and Global Communications. And within that overall team, there were several different branches dividing our roles.

I was a part of Multicultural Markets and Alliances, while the other intern I worked with was a part of Social Media. Of course, there were several other branches, including Internal and External Communication, Branding, PR, Government Affairs, and Corporate Social Responsibility. As the Multicultural Markets and Alliances Intern, my Manager was my direct report. The Vice President of Multicultural Markets and Alliances was my Mangers' direct report. And the Senior Vice President of PR and Global Communications was the Vice President of MMA's direct report.

According to Ronald Coase (1937), "every company will expand as long as the company's activities can be performed cheaper within the company, than by e.g. outsourcing the activities to external providers in the market." I was in-sourced by my manager into the company because it was more economic to contract an Intern, rather than to contract a third-party and utilize unnecessary resources to do what I already specialized in. The benefits of hiring me were high enough to cover the company's transaction costs. Had they outsourced, the transaction costs of that service would have been much higher than the benefits.

Wednesday, September 4, 2013

Peter Diamond

Peter Diamond, Huffington Post (06/06/11)

In October 2010, Peter Diamond was jointly awarded the Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel with two others "for their analysis of Markets with search frictions."1 But before he became an American Economist, he attended Yale where he majored in Mathematics and discovered his interest in Economics. Soon after graduating summa cum laude, he applied to graduate school at MIT for his Ph.D., where he now works as an Institute Professor in the Department of Economics.
"More generally, MIT was (and is) a terrific place to be a graduate student, to get an outstanding and broad education, while having a good time.  And it has been a terrific place to be a faculty member."2
Diamond stated that as an economist he has always been more interested in "working on models generating new insights, and not much in generalizations."2 His main fields include Search Theory and Labor Economics, where he has focused much of his professional career on the analysis of the U.S. Social Security policy.
"Family and economics have been the two poles around which I function, one a source of great joy and the other of great pleasure."2
In April 2010, President Barack Obama nominated Diamond to be one of the seven governors of the Fed, and renominated him again in September, and again in January when Republican Senators blocked the floor vote on his confirmation. He has since withdrawn from his nominations due to the opposition of the Senate.3

Diamond also came to the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign for a lecture series co-hosted by the Department of Economics, where he spoke on the topics of Unemployment and Government Debt. I had never heard of Peter Diamond before this course, however, I do believe his work in labor, welfare, and behavioral economics will be relevant to the economics we discuss as we attempt to understand certain organizational issues.



References

1 "The Prize in Economic Sciences 2010". Nobelprize.org. Nobel Media AB 2013. Web. 4 Sep 2013. <http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economic-sciences/laureates/2010/>
2 "Peter A. Diamond - Biographical". Nobelprize.org. Nobel Media AB 2013. Web. 4 Sep 2013. <http://www.nobelprize.org/nobel_prizes/economic-sciences/laureates/2010/diamond-bio.html>
3 Diamond, Peter. "When a Nobel Prize Isn’t Enough." The New York Times. The New York Times Company, 5 June 2011. Web. <http://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/06/opinion/06diamond.html>.